Skip to content

What’s behind Pierre Poilievre’s controversial drug coverage?

OTTAWA — Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre is promising a brand new strategy to managing Canada’s poisonous drug disaster, however what he is saying about that disaster is an irresponsible distortion of the information, his critics cost.

His guarantees — which embrace the suggestion he’d cut back safe-supply applications in favor of placing extra assets into habit therapy — mark a transfer for Poilievre away from the subjects he leaned on to win management of his celebration this 12 months and towards constructing a story to win authorities within the subsequent election.

Why he is specializing in drug coverage now, insiders say, follows his campaign-style tour by way of British Columbia this month the place he personally noticed among the impression of a drug disaster anticipated to kill greater than 2,000 individuals this 12 months.

Governments throughout the nation have been searching for solutions to an epidemic of poisonous drug use that has claimed 21 lives a day between January and March of this 12 months alone, federal statistics recommend.

In a video Poilievre made throughout a current journey to British Columbia, the epicenter of the disaster in Canada, he blamed the scenario on what he referred to as a “failed experiment” launched by “woke Liberal and NDP governments” to supply safer provides of illicit medicine .

“There is no such thing as a secure provide of those medicine. They’re lethal,” he stated.

“They’re deadly and they’re relentlessly addictive. Giving individuals extra of those medicine is not going to free them from their habit and can solely result in their final demise.”

As an alternative, Poilievre argued, the cash spent on secure provide ought to be redirected to habit therapy.

To again up his declare, he cites two knowledge factors: an assertion that overdose deaths are up in BC by 300 per cent since 2015, which he hyperlinks to secure provide regimes; and that overdose deaths have been reduce in half in Alberta, which he attributes to that province’s deal with therapy applications.

The statistics from the provinces present a extra nuanced look.

Alberta has elevated the variety of totally funded therapy beds by 476 since 2019, in keeping with evaluation by the Edmonton Journal, whereas in BC, 340 beds have been added over the past 5 years.

Knowledge from Alberta reveals that whereas overdose deaths have been declining since a month-to-month excessive of 174 final November, they’re nonetheless up from pre-pandemic ranges. On the identical time, demand for opioid substitutes or secure locations to make use of medicine — which preserve customers away from doubtlessly poisonous avenue medicine — can be up, provincial statistics present.

In the meantime, in BC, there have been 529 deaths attributed to poisonous drug overdoses in 2015, and 1,644 within the first eight months of 2022, in keeping with provincial statistics. In September alone, there have been 19,784 visits to overdose prevention and supervised consumption providers.

The safe-supply strategy — generally known as hurt discount — is what retains individuals from dying, Poilievre’s critics charged this week, and disposing of it dangers exacerbating the disaster.

Psychological Well being and Addictions Minister Carolyn Bennett, who earlier this week referred to as Poilievre’s feedback “populist nonsense,” reiterated that sentiment Wednesday in asserting $15 million in funding for substance abuse prevention programming.

Forty-two thousand overdoses have been reversed since 2017, she stated, and Poilievre’s place is “infuriating,” as the advantages of hurt discount and medication-assisted remedy are nicely understood.

“I do not know what a part of the proof the opponents are ignoring,” she stated.

However supporters of Poilievre’s place argue what he is being attentive to are perceptions that Canada’s drug issues are getting worse, not higher.

Political stress to current concepts on how one can deal with Canada’s poisonous drug difficulty has been constructing on the Conservatives, who till very just lately had framed the difficulty as a legal one which wanted to be handled by way of the justice system.

In 2021, nevertheless, then-leader Erin O’Toole started reframing drug use as a well being difficulty, promising to spend extra money on rehabilitation and therapy, and focusing regulation enforcement on the trafficking and importation of medicine—an strategy echoed by Poilievre.

Dan Robertson, who helped run O’Toole’s marketing campaign, stated the best way Poilievre goes on the difficulty is “lifeless on the cash.”

Whereas the Conservatives are derived for elevating crime as a problem even when statistics recommend it’s on the decline, that criticism would not stick if voters “really feel” it’s a drawback,” Robertson stated.

The identical is true of the drug disaster.

“All anybody has to do is stroll by way of the downtown of a metropolis on this nation and she or he will see throughout them that drug habit — and its attendant issues — has gotten a lot, a lot worse,” Robertson stated.

Poilievre’s deal with drug coverage now, insiders say, is linked to his campaign-style tour by way of British Columbia this month.

It wasn’t his first journey — he traveled extensively in BC throughout his profitable management marketing campaign earlier this 12 months, and did not debut any coverage on the difficulty at the moment.

However as his celebration begins to set the stage for the following election marketing campaign, ignoring the difficulty is not an possibility: the Conservatives misplaced 4 seats in British Columbia within the 2021 marketing campaign, and must win them again. Choosing up a couple of extra would not damage, both.

In that province, the drug epidemic is butting up in opposition to a housing disaster and an increase in violent crime, a mixture of points that performed out in that province’s municipal elections final month.

The outcomes — in Vancouver, specifically — are serving as a sign for Group Poilievre. Ken Sim, a right-of-centre mayoral candidate who targeted on public questions of safety, former NDP MP turned mayor Kennedy Stewart, who amongst different issues was a champion of drug decriminalization.

Federal Conservative insiders acknowledge it might really feel early to be testing out marketing campaign narratives for the following federal election—the supply-and-confidence settlement has the NDP propping up the minority Liberals till 2025 in trade for motion on NDP priorities.

However alternatively, it won’t, and within the meantime Poilievre is being inspired to test-drive ideas and approaches to see how they land.

Taking over the query of drug coverage additionally performs into Poilievre’s overarching model, Robertson identified.

“It suits into his ‘gatekeeper’ narrative, that so-called consultants do not actually know what they’re doing and are making issues worse.”


Conversations are opinions of our readers and are topic to the Code of Conduct. The Star doesn’t endorse these opinions.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *