Skip to content

‘Eileen’ Delivers a Stable Twist Even when It Comes Out of Left Area

Courtesy of Sundance Institute

Based mostly on the debut novel from PEN award winner Ottessa Moshfegh, Eileen is directed by William Oldroyd (Woman Macbeth) and stars Anne Hathaway (Armageddon Time) alongside Thomasin McKenzie (Final Night time in Soho).

A interval piece set in Fifties Boston, it charts the day by day grind of Eileen Dunlop (McKenzie), who lives together with her alcoholic father (Shea Wigham), works in a neighborhood jail, and breaks the monotony by disappearing into carnal daydreams. Trapped by circumstance and lack of ambition, Eileen will get a leap begin when the jail brings in Hathaway’s feminine psychiatrist Rebecca St. John.

Statuesque, stylish, and oozing glamor from each pore – she is a platinum blonde apparition who casts a spell over everybody. With a flattering wardrobe, an attractive decrease register to go with her bombshell look de ella, and greater than a bit moxie to again it up, Rebecca makes fairly the impression on Eileen.

Slowly however certainly that begins rubbing off, as Eileen sees her as a possible technique of escape from this down at heel existence. With a bit coaxing she is tempted out to the native bar for drinks and dancing, whereas locals look on in dismay. Conventions are challenged by these ladies, as Eileen begins caving in to the attraction she feels, whereas Rebecca’s affect from her steadily makes its mark.

Past these two actors, solely Whigham actually makes an impression as Eileen’s father, who has pushed himself to drink following the loss of life of his spouse. Emotionally spent, bloated via extra, and incapable of seeing previous the love he misplaced – there’s a tragic poignancy to be appreciated within the character which is crafted. With minimal screentime, the gifted character actor elevates an apparently one be aware function right into a heartbreaking eulogy, via the mix of a singular monologue second and his beneficiant co-star.

Elsewhere, Hathaway cuts a rug via this film, giving audiences an embodiment of St. John, somewhat than merely enjoying the half. In stark distinction to the dank situations which mark out her place of employment of her, she is each inch the 50s film icon minus trailing furs and gangster boyfriends. By comparability, McKenzie feels slight within the function of Eileen, by no means actually grabbing an viewers’s consideration, preferring as an alternative to accumulate and permit Hathaway to garner all that limelight.

For followers of Todd Haynes, there is no such thing as a getting away from the comparisons to Carol, which noticed Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara sort out the same dynamic. Because the older lady on this equation, Hathaway mirrors most of the efficiency decisions that are specified by Caroleven when the tone chosen by director Oldroyd makes issues really feel considerably completely different.

Eileen is much less about clandestine conferences, furtive glances, and secret tries at a time when two ladies being collectively was not possible. As an alternative, this movie depicts its femme fatale de ella as an unknown amount, who carries an air of mystique round her, which has much less to do with sexual liberation and extra to do with social non-conformity. It may very well be argued that these two go hand in glove, however with Carol the attraction angle was extra overt and revolved round class greater than the rest.

Nevertheless, comparisons with the Haynes film solely work up to a degree, since Eileen takes an odd flip within the closing third which undermines the extra nuanced decisions made early on. All through the movie obscure references and minor moments are proven, as Rebecca offers with younger offender Lee Polk (Sam Nivola). His de él is a wordless efficiency which feels surprisingly irrelevant till in a while, when Eileen ventures into chilly blooded interrogation territory.

Gone are the delicate moments of character development and nuanced dialogue exchanges, solely to get replaced by a guilt ridden confessional which can sucker punch audiences into submission. So far as dramatic U-turns are involved it is a actually doozy, which strips away the meek and gentle layers of McKenzie, changing them with exhausting edges sharp sufficient to slice you open.

In that second Eileen is perpetually modified, whereas Rebecca drops the facade and appears misplaced for the primary time. From a dramatic perspective, this growth feels at odds with all the pieces that got here earlier than, suggesting that there’s a good chunk of this movie taken out attributable to time constraints. A sense that by no means actually goes away, as these two ladies half firm and audiences are left with no actual sense of closure come the credit.


Director William Oldroyd provides up a 50s potboiler in ‘Eileen,’ which is held collectively by a chic Anne Hathaway and downtrodden Shea Whigham. Steeped in interval perfection however hampered by an off-kilter closing third, this may not be for everybody.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *