Skip to content

10 Cast Members Who Deserved Better

With the hype growing for the next season of the bachelorette, there’s no better time to think about past seasons. Regardless of whether these cast members made it to the finale or were released too soon, there are men from the bachelorette who can attest that the journey to find true love can feel like a rollercoaster — even more so on a six- to 10-week show.

Sometimes it takes more than one chance to find the perfect match, and some have been lucky enough to find love outside of reality TV. Others are still waiting for their soul mate. Meanwhile, many of these formerBachelorette the old ones remain in the public eye.

Tanner Tolbert

Her role in Kaitlyn Bristow Season 11 was mostly forgettable; however, Tanner Tolbert rose in Bachelor fandom due to his immediate chemistry with fellow week one Jade Roper. The two stayed together throughout the six weeks.

Although Tolbert banged on his appearance on Bachelorettehe found love in Bachelor in Paradise – where he and Roper were the only couple to get engaged in the finale and cement each other in Bachelor‘s popular alums. The couple now have three children together.

Adams Wells

Wells Adams was a contestant on Bachelorette, but JoJo Fletcher eliminated him during their one-on-one date because he failed to expand his interest beyond a platonic connection. Sparks didn’t seem to fly between the two, not compared to Fletcher’s chemistry with the “winner” – now spouse – Jordan Rodgers.

However, Adams became a fan favorite during his brief stint on BIP. In July 2019, he offered to modern familyIt’s Sara Hyland. After two years (due to the COVID pandemic), they finally put their wedding plans in motion (via Brides).

Blake Horstman

Many candidates felt that Becca Kufrin should have chosen Blake Horstmann to marry. However, he participated in several seasons of BIP, where he earned fans’ scorn for his playboy ways. Other fans are more lenient, saying Horstmann wasn’t related to anyone at the time. Fans are hoping he finds someone to share his adventurous lifestyle with.

In January 2022, People reported that the former Bachelorette competitor and Love is blindby Giannina Gibelli are dating. However, none of their social media accounts encouraged speculation that they were still together.

Jason Tartic

Although he has become a fan favorite and favourite, Jason Tartick was eliminated just before the fantasy sequel dates. Becca Kufrin revealed that she felt their bond with him was not as strong as her other relationships; they said goodbye that night.

Tartick is another season 14 reject, but serendipitously he and the former Bachelorette Kaitlyn Bristow tuned in on an episode of her podcast, off the vine. The couple announced their engagement in May 2019 (via We Weekly).

Joe Amabile

For his charming good looks and fun personality, fans were sad to see “Grocery Store” Joe Amabile go home in Week 1, but he was quickly picked up for BIP.

While he was eliminated in his first season with the spin-off, he revived with the old Bachelor contestant Kendall Long. The couple dated for two years before going their separate ways. Amabile returned for Season 7 and went to the finale with Serena Pitt, where he went on his knees. The two are still together, according to life and style.

mike johnson

Air Force veteran Mike Johnson was knocked out in Week 7 just before hometown visits. During their one-on-one date, Hannah Brown confessed that she wasn’t for him, and fans could tell he was blindsided by her tearful goodbye.

Johnson was confident but cordial, and with his gorgeous smile and genuine personality, fans speculated (even hopefully anticipated) that he might be in contention for the next one. Bachelor (Going through Heavy entertainment). Currently, there is no confirmed information on his relationship status beyond 2021.

Tyler Cameron

As Tyler Cameron began to explain his feelings for Hannah Brown in the finale, she had to cut him off because she knew he was leading to a proposal. Although he took his reasons for rejection without flinching, it was still hard to see his broken heart.

Thankfully, neither seem to hold themselves in deep contempt. After the show aired, the exes finally “buried the hatchet” (via Youtube) and became quarantine pals. Single again, Cameron reported to Today let him focus on his career right now.

Chris Harrison

Some fans believe former host Chris Harrison was forced to ‘walk away’ from Bachelor. In hindsight, it was definitely ill-advised to publicly defend a controversial candidate: Rachael Kirkconnell appeared “in photos attending a pre-war plantation-themed fraternity ceremony in 2018” (via BNC News).

While this is an unpopular view, few fans think others should have shown more grace instead of demanding Harrison’s head in the wake of “the cancellation of the culture”. Ancient Bachelor Sean Lowe explained, “The cross is where grace is given (via Reddit).”

Greg Grippo

Greg Grippo had cultivated a stable relationship with the bachelor of his season, but their bond took a nosedive after their hometown dates. He confessed to Katie Thurston that he loved her, but he felt his confession fell on deaf ears.

Grippo admitted, “I’ve reached my breaking point” (via Youtube). In her defense, some fans believe Thurston was caught off guard and ended their relationship before she could adequately explain herself. Either way, Grippo has moved on and is dating “someone new” (via The Viall files).

Joe Colman

During Michelle Young’s season on the bachelorette, Joe Coleman was an early favorite, as the two had mutual friends, hobbies, and even attended the same alma mater in Minnesota. It came as a shock to fans when Young told Joe she couldn’t “be your person” (via Youtube).

The farewell was heartbreaking but heartfelt, and it left fans hoping Joe could be next. Bachelor. Alas, The Bachelor announced that Clayton Echard would be directing Season 26 instead.

90 Day Fiancé: Angela’s Controversial Makeup Takes Care of Weight Loss

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.